Why a gas forge suits beginning bladesmiths
Most people who start making knives today start with a propane forge. Coal and charcoal still work well, and plenty of smiths prefer them, but a gas forge has a few things going for it when you’re learning:
- It’s predictable. Once you’ve set the regulator, the forge holds a fairly steady temperature. You aren’t managing a fire as well as a piece of steel.
- It’s clean to start and stop. Turn the valve on, light it, and you’re forging within a few minutes of warm-up. Turn it off and you’re done. There’s no clinker to deal with and no coal to store.
- It heats evenly along a blade. A well-designed chamber surrounds the steel with hot gas, which helps when you need the whole length of a blade at the same temperature.
- It’s easy to find fuel. Propane cylinders are sold almost everywhere.
The trade-offs are real too. A gas forge burns fuel the whole time it’s lit, whether or not there’s steel in it. It produces carbon monoxide. And the inside of the forge can get hotter than a thin knife edge can handle, which catches out a lot of beginners during heat treatment.
This guide covers how gas forges work, how to set one up safely, and how to forge, normalize and heat treat a simple knife in one.
How a gas forge works
A gas forge is an insulated chamber with one or more burners firing into it. The burner mixes propane with air and the mixture burns inside the chamber. The insulation keeps the heat in and the inner walls glow, so the steel is heated both by the flame and by radiant heat from the walls.
Atmospheric (venturi) vs. blown burners
There are two common burner designs:
- Atmospheric or venturi burners use the speed of the gas jet to pull air in through an opening at the back of the burner tube. They need no electricity and are quiet-ish, simple and cheap. Most entry-level commercial forges use them. Their main downside is that the fuel-to-air ratio depends on gas pressure and burner tuning, so you have less independent control.
- Blown (forced-air) burners use a blower to push air into the burner, with gas added through a valve. You can adjust air and gas separately, which makes it easier to tune the atmosphere in the forge and to run at low temperatures. They need power and are a little more complicated to set up.
Either type will make knives. Atmospheric forges are the usual starting point because there’s less to go wrong.
Refractory lining: blanket, castable and firebrick
The lining matters as much as the burner. Common materials include:
- Ceramic fiber blanket. A lightweight wool-like insulation rated for high temperatures. It heats up quickly and insulates very well. The fibers can irritate skin and lungs, though, and some types are treated as a potential long-term health hazard. Blanket should never be left exposed inside a forge. It’s normally rigidized and then covered with a castable or refractory coating so the flame and your tongs can’t knock fibers loose. Wear a suitable dust mask or respirator, gloves and long sleeves when handling it.
- Castable refractory. A cement-like material that’s cast or troweled over the blanket to form a hard inner shell. It protects the blanket and stands up to scale and flux better.
- Insulating firebrick (soft brick). Light, easy to cut and a decent insulator. It’s often used for forge floors or doors, or for simple “brick pile” forges. Soft brick wears quickly under flux and scale.
- Kiln shelf or hard brick floors. Some smiths add a hard floor to resist flux, which eats ordinary linings when you forge weld.
Chamber size and burner count
A bigger chamber isn’t automatically better. The more internal volume you have, the more fuel you need to keep it hot. Many builders aim for a chamber just large enough for the work they plan to do. For knives, that usually means a long, fairly narrow chamber.
Single-burner forges are fine for small knives and general forging. Two- or three-burner forges heat a longer section evenly, which helps with longer blades, heat treating and forge welding billets. Some multi-burner forges let you run just one burner when you only need a short hot zone, which saves fuel.
Buy or build?
Plenty of smiths build their own gas forge from a steel shell, ceramic blanket, castable and a homemade or purchased burner. It can be cheaper, and you learn a lot about how the forge behaves. But a poorly built burner can be hard to tune, and an unprotected lining can shed fibers.
If you’re brand new, a commercial forge from an established maker is the simplest way to start. You can always build a second forge later once you know what you want.
What to look for in a commercial forge
- Chamber length and opening size that match the blades you want to make. A slot or rear port that lets you pass longer stock through helps.
- Lining quality. Check that the blanket is coated and not left as bare fiber.
- Regulator and hose included, with an adjustable regulator and a gauge. A fixed low-pressure barbecue regulator won’t usually let you run a forge properly.
- Burner count and controls. Separate valves for each burner add flexibility.
- Floor material that can stand up to flux if you plan to forge weld.
- A stable stand or legs so the forge can’t tip.
Don’t rely only on the maximum temperature in a product listing. Real-world temperatures depend on how you tune it, the gas pressure and how much the door is open.
Setting up safely
Ventilation and carbon monoxide
A propane forge produces carbon monoxide (CO), which you can’t see or smell. It can build up quickly in an enclosed garage or shed. Forge outdoors or in a well-ventilated space with a steady supply of fresh air, and put a CO detector in the workspace. If you get a headache, dizziness or nausea while forging, turn the forge off and get outside.
The forge also throws hot exhaust out of its openings. Keep flammable materials well away from the front and back of the forge, and don’t point it at walls, curtains or the propane cylinder.
Propane supply, regulators and leak checks
- Use an adjustable propane regulator with a gauge, hose rated for propane, and correctly tightened fittings.
- Leak test every new connection with soapy water before lighting. Bubbles mean a leak. Never use a flame to look for one.
- Keep the cylinder upright, outside the hot zone and away from the forge’s exhaust.
- Follow the forge maker’s lighting procedure exactly. If the forge fails to light, shut the gas off and let the chamber clear before trying again.
- If you run a forge hard for a long time, a small cylinder can get very cold and the pressure can drop. A larger cylinder helps.
- Have a fire extinguisher suitable for the space and a bucket of water nearby, and wear cotton or wool rather than synthetic clothing.
Safety glasses are essential at every stage. Hearing protection helps too, because a forge plus hammering is louder than it seems.
Choosing steel for your first blade
Steel choice makes a bigger difference to how your first knife turns out than almost anything else. A simple carbon steel with a known composition is much easier to heat treat than a mystery piece of scrap. Our article on the best steel for your first forged knife explains why 1084 is the usual recommendation, and what alternatives make sense.
A typical starting bar for a small utility knife is roughly 1/4 inch (6 mm) thick and 3/4 to 1 inch (19 to 25 mm) wide, but you can start smaller. Thinner stock is quicker to forge and more forgiving if your hammer control is still developing.
Forging a knife in a gas forge, step by step
Heating the bar
Let the forge come up to temperature before you put the steel in. Forging temperatures for simple carbon steels are a bright orange to yellow. Every steel has its own range, so check the supplier’s data. Keep an eye on the steel rather than the clock. Thin sections heat much faster than thick ones, and the tip of a blade can overheat while the thicker part is still coming up to temperature.
Don’t keep forging once the steel has dropped to a dull red. Hammering steel that’s too cold can cause cracks, especially near the edge and tip. Put it back in the forge and reheat. Short, focused heats are better than one long session at the anvil.
Don’t leave steel sitting in a hot forge for a long time. That causes heavy scale and, for carbon steel, loses some carbon from the surface (decarburization).
Forging the point and profile
Most beginners forge the point first:
- Heat the end of the bar.
- Hammer the corner on one side to taper it. This forms the tip.
- Turn the bar on edge and knock the curve back so the tip sits where you want it. The edge side will curve upward later as you forge the bevels, so many smiths forge the tip so it starts slightly “down”.
- Draw out the tang if you’re making a full or hidden tang, keeping it centered and straight.
Forging the bevels and distal taper
Forging the bevels thins the edge side of the blade. As the edge side spreads, the blade curves away from the edge toward the spine. That’s why it pays to pre-curve the blade in the other direction, or to straighten it on edge as you go.
Work evenly on both faces. Keep the edge reasonably thick, perhaps the thickness of a coin, rather than forging it thin. A very thin forged edge overheats easily, can crack and is hard to keep straight during heat treatment. You’ll remove the rest with files or a grinder.
Many smiths also forge a distal taper, meaning the blade gets thinner toward the tip. It makes the knife lighter at the point and better balanced.
Straighten the blade regularly while it’s hot, both on the flat and on edge. Small corrections are much easier than big ones at the end.
Normalizing and annealing
Forging leaves stress and uneven grain in the steel. Normalizing means heating the blade above its critical temperature and letting it cool in still air. Many smiths do this a few times at progressively lower temperatures to refine the grain before hardening.
If you plan to file or drill the blade by hand, an anneal softens the steel further. The process depends on the steel, and the heat treating guide covers it in more detail.
Grinding
After normalizing, clean up the profile and bevels with files, a belt grinder or an angle grinder. Leave the edge slightly thick before hardening, roughly the thickness of a coin or a bit less. That helps prevent cracks and warping in the quench. You’ll take it down to final sharpness after tempering.
Drill handle pin holes and finish rough shaping before hardening, because hardened steel is very difficult to drill.
Heat treating with a gas forge
A gas forge can work for hardening, but it needs care. Many forges run well above the temperature a simple carbon steel needs for hardening, and a thin blade can overshoot in seconds. Some ways to make it more controllable:
- Turn the gas pressure down after forging and let the forge settle.
- Put the blade inside a steel pipe (a muffle) in the forge. The pipe heats evenly and shields the blade from the direct flame.
- Keep the blade moving so the edge and tip don’t get ahead of the spine.
- Use a magnet to check for loss of magnetism and use a thermocouple if you have one.
The full process for normalizing, hardening, quenching and tempering is covered in our guide to how to heat treat a knife at home.
Forge welding and Damascus in a gas forge
Gas forges can reach forge welding temperatures, and many pattern-welded billets are made in them. Welding needs a hotter forge and usually flux, which attacks most linings. A sacrificial floor or a flux-resistant coating helps your forge last.
Forge welding is a step up from forging a single bar of steel, so most people make several simple knives first. Once you’re comfortable, you can move on to layered billets. Our guide to making mosaic Damascus steel covers the cut-and-restack and canister methods, and what is the hardest Damascus pattern to make explains why some patterns take far more work than others. If you’re curious how modern pattern-welded “Damascus” relates to the historical crucible steel, see why we supposedly can’t recreate Damascus steel.
Common beginner problems
- Heavy scale and pitting. The steel spent too long in the forge, or the forge is running with too much air. Shorter heats and a slightly richer flame help.
- Cracks at the tip or edge. Usually caused by forging too cold or forging the edge too thin.
- A blade that keeps curving. Bevel forging naturally curves the blade. Straighten on edge often, and pre-curve the blank.
- Warping in the quench. Uneven heating, uneven grinding or an edge that’s too thin. Even heating and a symmetrical blank help most.
- A forge that won’t stay lit or roars and spits. Usually a burner tuning, gas pressure or air supply issue. Check the manufacturer’s instructions before modifying anything.
- A blade that won’t harden. Often the steel isn’t a hardenable carbon steel, it wasn’t heated enough, or the quench was too slow. A known steel removes most of the guesswork.
Where to go next
The quickest way to improve is to forge a lot of simple blades and get feedback from experienced makers. Hands-on classes, local blacksmithing groups and knife shows are all good places to learn. If you’re in the UK, the British Knife Makers Guild is one place to see how established makers work and to meet people in the craft.