Metals and Fuel

Coal vs Coke vs Charcoal: Choosing a Solid Forge Fuel

Bituminous coal, coke and charcoal compared for forging: heat, smoke, sulfur, clinker, air needs, fuel use and cost, plus which solid fuel suits your forge and site.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Bituminous coal
  3. Coke
  4. Charcoal
  5. What about anthracite and briquettes?
  6. Side-by-side comparison
  7. Which fuel should you choose?
  8. Safety with any solid fuel

The short answer

  • Bituminous coal is the traditional forge fuel. It makes a compact, controllable fire that’s easy to shape, but it smokes when you light it, needs clinker removed and must be low in sulfur.
  • Coke is coal with the smoky volatiles already cooked off. It burns hot and relatively clean, but it’s harder to light and tends to go out quickly without a steady air blast.
  • Charcoal is clean, low in sulfur, easy to light and widely available, but it burns quickly, throws sparks and you’ll use a lot more of it by volume.

If you can get good, low-sulfur blacksmith coal and smoke isn’t a problem where you work, coal is the most versatile choice. If smoke is a problem, coke or charcoal are the usual answers. Many beginners also choose propane instead of any solid fuel.

Bituminous coal

Good blacksmith coal is a low-sulfur, low-ash bituminous coal that cokes well, meaning its particles soften and fuse into a spongy mass as they heat.

How it works in the forge: You light a small fire, pile damp coal around it, and the heat slowly cooks the outer coal into coke. You then push that coke into the centre of the fire as fuel. The fire is built and maintained by the smith rather than simply fed.

Pros

  • a compact, deep, controllable heat that’s easy to shape for long or local heats
  • holds heat between blasts better than coke
  • versatile for everything from scrolls to forge welds

Cons

  • thick yellow smoke while the fire is getting going and when green coal is added
  • produces clinker (fused ash) that must be removed during long sessions
  • sulfur in poor coal can contaminate steel and make forge welding difficult
  • good smithing coal can be hard to find in some regions, as covered in can you still buy coal?

For what coal actually contains and why sulfur and ash matter, see what coal is made of.

Coke

Coke is made by heating coal without enough air to burn it, driving off the volatile matter. What’s left is mostly carbon plus ash. Commercial coke and the coke you make in a coal fire are essentially the same thing, though commercial coke can be denser and harder to light.

Pros

  • far less smoke than raw coal
  • burns very hot
  • usually lower in sulfur than raw coal, depending on the source

Cons

  • harder to light; usually needs a wood or charcoal kindling fire first
  • needs a continuous air blast, and tends to die quickly once air stops
  • can be pricey or hard to buy in small bags depending on where you live
  • large commercial “foundry” or industrial coke may need breaking to a suitable size for a hand forge

Coke suits smiths with a reliable electric blower who forge in steady sessions.

Charcoal

Use lump charcoal, which is wood heated without air. Barbecue briquettes contain binders and fillers and produce lots of ash.

Pros

  • very low sulfur, so it’s friendly to steel and forge welding
  • lights easily and gets hot quickly
  • available from hardware stores and grocery shops, or you can make it yourself
  • little smoke once it’s burning

Cons

  • burns fast, so you’ll go through a large volume per session
  • throws plenty of sparks, especially with a strong blast; take care with clothing and nearby flammables
  • the fire is less stable to shape than a coal fire
  • lump size is inconsistent; break larger pieces to a uniform size

Charcoal generally works best with a gentle, steady air supply and a fire bed that’s deeper or wider than a coal fire. Many smiths use a side-blast forge or a deep firepot for it. Charcoal was the forge fuel for most of history, from bloomeries to medieval smithies. It’s fully capable of welding heat.

What about anthracite and briquettes?

Anthracite (hard coal), the type commonly sold in bags for heating stoves, is high in carbon and low in volatiles. It’s difficult to light and keep going in a typical small forge. It needs a constant strong blast and doesn’t coke and stick together the way bituminous coal does. Some smiths make it work, but it’s generally a poor substitute for blacksmith coal.

Charcoal briquettes are not recommended. The binders and fillers produce excessive ash and an unpleasant, unstable fire.

Side-by-side comparison

Bituminous coal Coke Charcoal
Ease of lighting Moderate Hard Easy
Smoke Heavy while lighting and adding fuel Low Low once burning
Air needs Moderate, can rest between blasts Constant blast Gentle, steady
Sulfur Varies; buy low-sulfur Usually lower than raw coal Very low
Clinker and ash Clinker to remove Some ash and clinker Light ash, little clinker
Fuel used per session Moderate Moderate High by volume
Sparks Some Some Many
Availability Patchy in many areas Patchy Widespread

Which fuel should you choose?

  • You can buy good blacksmith coal and smoke is acceptable: coal. It’s the most flexible fire to learn on and is what most traditional instruction assumes.
  • You’re in a suburb or smoke draws complaints: coke or charcoal, or consider a propane forge.
  • You only have a hand-crank or occasional air: coal or charcoal will tolerate pauses better than coke.
  • You’re doing historical work or don’t want to rely on coal suppliers: charcoal.
  • You’re in a region where smithing coal is scarce: see our notes on buying blacksmith coal in Canada, which apply to anywhere coal is hard to find.

Safety with any solid fuel

  • Carbon monoxide is produced by every solid fuel fire. Only forge with good ventilation, outdoors or under a properly designed hood and chimney.
  • Keep a bucket of water and a fire extinguisher at hand, and clear the area of flammables.
  • Wear natural-fibre clothing. Synthetic fabrics can melt onto skin when sparks land on them.
  • Let ash and clinker cool fully in a metal container before disposing of them.

The complete guide to metals and fuel

What Wrought Iron Is Used For
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →