Metals and Fuel

What is coal made of?

Coal is made mostly of carbon from ancient plant remains, plus hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur and mineral ash. Here's what each part does in a blacksmith's forge.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. The main ingredients of coal
  3. How plants become coal
  4. The ranks of coal
  5. What coal’s makeup means at the forge
  6. What coke is made of

The short answer

Coal is made from the remains of ancient plants that were buried, compressed and heated over millions of years. Chemically it’s mostly carbon, with smaller amounts of hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen and sulfur, plus mineral matter that stays behind as ash when coal burns. It also contains varying amounts of moisture and volatile matter, the gases and tars released when coal is heated.

Exact proportions vary a lot between coals. Higher-rank coals such as anthracite contain more carbon and less moisture and volatiles than lower-rank coals such as lignite.

The main ingredients of coal

Carbon

Carbon is the main ingredient and the source of most of coal’s heat. In US Energy Information Administration classifications, carbon content runs from roughly 25–35% in lignite up to roughly 86–97% in anthracite. Some of the carbon is “fixed carbon” that burns as a solid. The rest is bound up in compounds that are released as volatile matter.

Hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen

These come from the original plant material. Hydrogen and oxygen are released largely as gases and tars during heating. Lower-rank coals hold more oxygen and moisture, while higher-rank coals have lost more of both.

Sulfur

Sulfur comes partly from the plants and partly from the swamp water and minerals around them. It’s often present as iron sulfide (pyrite) and as organic sulfur compounds. Sulfur content varies greatly from one coal seam to another, and it’s one of the biggest factors in whether a coal is any good for forging.

Mineral matter (ash)

Clay, silt, sand and other minerals were washed into the peat or formed within the seam. When coal burns, this material is left as ash. In a forge it can fuse into clinker, a glassy lump that collects at the bottom of the fire.

Moisture and volatile matter

Coal contains water, from very high levels in lignite to quite little in anthracite. Volatile matter is the mix of gases and tars driven off by heat. It produces the smoke and flame when coal is first lit.

How plants become coal

  1. Plants accumulate in swamps. Trees, ferns, mosses and other wetland plants die and fall into waterlogged ground.
  2. Peat forms. Low-oxygen water slows decay, so the plant matter builds up as spongy peat rather than rotting away.
  3. Burial. Layers of sediment bury the peat deeper over long periods.
  4. Coalification. Heat and pressure drive off water and gases and concentrate carbon. The longer and more intensely this goes on, the higher the coal’s rank.

Many of the world’s major coal deposits formed from vegetation that grew hundreds of millions of years ago, though coal of many different ages exists.

The ranks of coal

Rank Typical character Approx. carbon (EIA)
Lignite Soft, brown, very moist, crumbly ~25–35%
Subbituminous Dull black, still fairly moist ~35–45%
Bituminous Black, often banded, higher heat value ~45–86%
Anthracite Hard, shiny, low volatiles, burns with little smoke ~86–97%

What coal’s makeup means at the forge

Every part of coal’s composition shows up in a blacksmith’s fire:

  • Volatile matter causes the thick smoke when you light a coal forge. In good blacksmith coal, the heat cooks out these volatiles and turns the coal into coke, which then burns hot and fairly cleanly. That’s why smiths wet raw coal around the edge of the fire and push it in once it has coked.
  • Coking quality comes from bituminous coal’s ability to soften and fuse as it heats. That lets you build a compact, shaped fire. Anthracite doesn’t coke this way and is hard to manage in most small forges.
  • Sulfur is the enemy. It can transfer to hot steel, making forge welds hard to achieve and sometimes leaving the steel brittle. Smiths look for coal described as low-sulfur, often quoted as under about 1%.
  • Ash becomes clinker. Low-ash coal makes less clinker, so you spend less time cleaning the fire.

That’s why bituminous coal with low sulfur, low ash and good coking quality is what’s sold as “blacksmith coal.” It’s also why bagged heating anthracite often disappoints in a forge. For help tracking down the right kind, see can you still buy coal?.

What coke is made of

Coke is what’s left when coal is heated without enough air to burn it. Most of the volatile matter, along with much of the hydrogen and oxygen, is driven off, leaving mainly carbon plus the original ash. Some sulfur usually remains. Coke burns hot with little smoke but needs a steady air blast. For a full comparison with coal and charcoal as forge fuels, see coal vs coke vs charcoal.

The complete guide to metals and fuel

What Wrought Iron Is Used For
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →