The short answer
For most beginners, a small propane forge with one or two burners is the easiest place to start. It lights in seconds, needs little fire management, gives a fairly even heat, and propane is easy to buy almost everywhere.
That said, propane isn’t the only good choice. A coal forge is excellent if you have a reliable source of good blacksmithing coal and space where smoke won’t bother anyone. A charcoal forge is often the cheapest way to start. The best forge for you depends on your fuel supply, your space and what you want to make.
Propane forges
Pros:
- Quick to light and shut down
- Little smoke; easier to use near neighbors
- Fairly even, consistent heat inside the chamber
- Simple to learn; you adjust heat with the regulator
- Clean heat that suits knife work and heat treating
Cons:
- The enclosed chamber limits the size and shape of stock, and heating just one spot on a long piece is harder
- Requires an adjustable regulator, proper hose and safe gas handling
- Fuel costs can add up, and small tanks can freeze up on long sessions (see how long a 20 lb propane tank lasts on a forge)
- The ceramic fiber lining needs to be coated and maintained
Coal forges
Pros:
- Can get very hot, with a highly localized heat
- An open fire takes awkward shapes and lets you heat just one section
- Traditional, and very versatile for general blacksmithing
- Plenty of older books and teachers assume a coal forge
Cons:
- Good coal can be hard to find in some areas
- Produces smoke and needs ventilation and a chimney indoors
- Managing the fire (clinker, coke, fire size) takes practice
- More risk of burning thin stock if you’re not paying attention
Charcoal forges
Pros:
- Charcoal is widely available
- Simple, cheap forges such as the JABOD work well
- Clean-burning compared with coal; little sulfur
Cons:
- Burns quickly, so you’ll use a lot of it
- Throws sparks
- Needs forced air, like coal
What about electric and induction?
Induction heaters can heat steel quickly and precisely. Some smiths use them, especially for repetitive work on similar-sized stock. They tend to be expensive, and each coil suits a limited range of shapes and sizes. For a first forge they’re usually not where people start, but they are an option if you have the budget.
Match the forge to what you want to make
- Knives and small blades: a propane forge suits most knife work. The chamber should fit the blade length you plan to make, and some knifemakers later add a dedicated heat-treating setup.
- Hooks, small tools and general smithing: any of the three fuels works. A small propane forge or a simple coal or charcoal setup is plenty.
- Large or awkward pieces, scrolls and gates: an open coal or charcoal fire is more flexible.
- Forge welding: possible in all three, but your forge needs to reach and hold welding heat. See how hot does a propane forge get.
Buy or build?
Buying gets you forging sooner and takes much of the guesswork out of burner tuning. Building costs less in money and teaches you how a forge works, which helps when you need to fix or improve it.
Both work. If you’d like to build, start with our beginner’s guide to building a blacksmith forge, or see building a forge on a budget if money is tight. For a propane build specifically, see building a gas bottle propane forge and burners.
What to check before you buy a beginner forge
Low-cost commercial forges are popular, and many work well enough, but quality varies. Look for or plan to address:
- Exposed ceramic wool. Many budget forges ship with uncoated wool. Rigidizing and coating it reduces airborne fibers and makes the lining last longer. See lining a gas forge.
- The regulator. Check that it’s adjustable and has a gauge.
- The floor. A hard firebrick or refractory floor is much more durable than wool.
- The door openings. Make sure they’re big enough for your stock without being huge.
- The burner. You’ll want to be able to adjust it; some are easier to tune than others. See how to tune a propane forge burner.
- The size. A forge that’s too large wastes fuel; one that’s too small limits your projects.
Our recommendation
If you have no strong reason to choose otherwise, start with a small one- or two-burner propane forge, either bought or built. Coat the lining, use a proper adjustable regulator, and forge outdoors or in a well-ventilated space. If you have easy access to good coal and space for smoke, a simple coal forge is an equally valid first forge and teaches excellent fire control. If budget is the deciding factor, a charcoal JABOD will get you started for very little.