Forge Building

What is the best forge for beginners?

For most beginners a small propane forge is easiest, but coal and charcoal have real advantages. Compare fuels, build vs buy, and what to check in a cheap forge.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Propane forges
  3. Coal forges
  4. Charcoal forges
  5. What about electric and induction?
  6. Match the forge to what you want to make
  7. Buy or build?
  8. What to check before you buy a beginner forge
  9. Our recommendation

The short answer

For most beginners, a small propane forge with one or two burners is the easiest place to start. It lights in seconds, needs little fire management, gives a fairly even heat, and propane is easy to buy almost everywhere.

That said, propane isn’t the only good choice. A coal forge is excellent if you have a reliable source of good blacksmithing coal and space where smoke won’t bother anyone. A charcoal forge is often the cheapest way to start. The best forge for you depends on your fuel supply, your space and what you want to make.

Propane forges

Pros:

  • Quick to light and shut down
  • Little smoke; easier to use near neighbors
  • Fairly even, consistent heat inside the chamber
  • Simple to learn; you adjust heat with the regulator
  • Clean heat that suits knife work and heat treating

Cons:

  • The enclosed chamber limits the size and shape of stock, and heating just one spot on a long piece is harder
  • Requires an adjustable regulator, proper hose and safe gas handling
  • Fuel costs can add up, and small tanks can freeze up on long sessions (see how long a 20 lb propane tank lasts on a forge)
  • The ceramic fiber lining needs to be coated and maintained

Coal forges

Pros:

  • Can get very hot, with a highly localized heat
  • An open fire takes awkward shapes and lets you heat just one section
  • Traditional, and very versatile for general blacksmithing
  • Plenty of older books and teachers assume a coal forge

Cons:

  • Good coal can be hard to find in some areas
  • Produces smoke and needs ventilation and a chimney indoors
  • Managing the fire (clinker, coke, fire size) takes practice
  • More risk of burning thin stock if you’re not paying attention

Charcoal forges

Pros:

Cons:

  • Burns quickly, so you’ll use a lot of it
  • Throws sparks
  • Needs forced air, like coal

What about electric and induction?

Induction heaters can heat steel quickly and precisely. Some smiths use them, especially for repetitive work on similar-sized stock. They tend to be expensive, and each coil suits a limited range of shapes and sizes. For a first forge they’re usually not where people start, but they are an option if you have the budget.

Match the forge to what you want to make

Buy or build?

Buying gets you forging sooner and takes much of the guesswork out of burner tuning. Building costs less in money and teaches you how a forge works, which helps when you need to fix or improve it.

Both work. If you’d like to build, start with our beginner’s guide to building a blacksmith forge, or see building a forge on a budget if money is tight. For a propane build specifically, see building a gas bottle propane forge and burners.

What to check before you buy a beginner forge

Low-cost commercial forges are popular, and many work well enough, but quality varies. Look for or plan to address:

  • Exposed ceramic wool. Many budget forges ship with uncoated wool. Rigidizing and coating it reduces airborne fibers and makes the lining last longer. See lining a gas forge.
  • The regulator. Check that it’s adjustable and has a gauge.
  • The floor. A hard firebrick or refractory floor is much more durable than wool.
  • The door openings. Make sure they’re big enough for your stock without being huge.
  • The burner. You’ll want to be able to adjust it; some are easier to tune than others. See how to tune a propane forge burner.
  • The size. A forge that’s too large wastes fuel; one that’s too small limits your projects.

Our recommendation

If you have no strong reason to choose otherwise, start with a small one- or two-burner propane forge, either bought or built. Coat the lining, use a proper adjustable regulator, and forge outdoors or in a well-ventilated space. If you have easy access to good coal and space for smoke, a simple coal forge is an equally valid first forge and teaches excellent fire control. If budget is the deciding factor, a charcoal JABOD will get you started for very little.

The complete guide to forge building

How to Build Your Own Blacksmith Forge: Plans for Beginners
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →