The short answer
A well-built, well-insulated propane forge typically reaches somewhere around 2,000 to 2,400°F (about 1,100 to 1,300°C) inside the chamber. Some designs get hotter. Commonly quoted maximums for strong forges run up to the mid-2,000s °F. That’s more than enough for general forging, and many forges can reach forge-welding heat.
How hot your forge gets depends on the burner, the insulation, the chamber size and how it’s tuned. Two forges on the same tank can perform very differently.
Temperatures by task
These are approximate ranges for plain carbon steels. Specific alloys have their own recommended temperatures, so check the steel supplier’s data for anything important.
| Task | Approximate temperature | Typical color (in shade) |
|---|---|---|
| Hardening simple carbon steels | Roughly 1,450–1,550°F (about 790–840°C) | Medium to bright red |
| General forging | Roughly 1,700–2,100°F (about 930–1,150°C) | Orange to yellow |
| Forge welding | Roughly 2,200–2,400°F (about 1,200–1,320°C) | Bright yellow to near-white |
A common rule of thumb for many simple carbon steels is that they reach hardening temperature a little above the point where they stop attracting a magnet. Forge welding usually uses a flux, such as borax, to protect the joint surfaces. See lining a gas forge for how flux affects the forge floor.
What affects how hot your forge gets
- Burner design and output. A well-made burner delivering enough gas, at the right mix, is the starting point. Some designs simply run hotter than others.
- Number of burners vs. chamber volume. A chamber too big for its burners won’t get as hot. A common guideline is roughly one 3/4-inch venturi burner per 300–350 cubic inches of chamber.
- Insulation. Thicker, well-coated insulation keeps more heat in. Thin or damaged linings, or dense brick, absorb and lose heat.
- Door and exhaust openings. Every opening lets heat out. Partly closing them with loose firebrick can make a noticeable difference.
- Gas pressure. Within your burner’s working range, more pressure generally means more heat and more fuel use.
- Fuel-air mix. A badly tuned burner, too rich or too lean, won’t reach its potential. See how to tune a propane forge burner.
- Tank pressure. A cold or nearly empty tank delivers less gas, so the forge cools even if you haven’t touched the regulator. See how long a 20 lb propane tank lasts on a forge.
- Weather. A cold, windy day outdoors pulls heat from the forge shell and the tank.
Why the temperature drops when you load cold steel
Smiths often notice that the chamber temperature falls sharply the first time they put a cold piece of steel in, then recovers slowly. One forum user reported a drop of several hundred degrees and around ten minutes to recover early in a session. Later loads had much less effect.
The likely reason is that early on, the chamber air may be hot but the lining hasn’t fully heated through. Cold steel draws heat out faster than the lining can give it back. Once the lining is fully hot it acts as a heat reservoir, and recovery is quicker. Giving the forge a little extra warm-up time before the first heat helps.
How to measure forge temperature
- Thermocouple and pyrometer. A thermocouple probe through the forge wall, connected to a digital readout, gives an actual number. Type K thermocouples are common and inexpensive, but are generally rated to around 2,300°F. Near welding heat that’s at or beyond their limit, and they degrade faster there. Use a probe with a suitable protective sheath, and expect to replace probes over time.
- PID controllers. Some builders connect a thermocouple to a controller that adjusts the gas automatically. This is popular for heat treating and for holding a set temperature.
- Steel color. Experienced smiths judge heat by color, but color looks very different in bright sunlight versus a dim shop. If you go by color, work in consistent, fairly subdued light.
- Magnet test. For simple carbon steels, the point where a magnet stops sticking is a useful marker around hardening temperature. It doesn’t tell you anything about forging or welding heat.
Can a forge get too hot?
Yes, in a few ways:
- Burning the steel. Carbon steel held too hot for too long can be damaged. You may see sparks coming from the steel itself, a sign it’s burning. Burnt steel is generally scrap.
- Lining damage. Running hotter than the lining’s rating can shrink ceramic wool, crack coatings and shorten its life. Check the temperature ratings of your wool and refractory.
- Grain growth. Repeatedly overheating steel, especially blade steels, can coarsen its grain structure and reduce toughness.
- Wasted fuel. Running at welding heat for ordinary forging burns more propane without any benefit.
Getting to welding heat
If your forge struggles to reach welding temperature:
- Check the lining is thick, coated and in good condition.
- Reduce openings with loose firebrick while welding.
- Tune the burner to a clean, slightly rich mix.
- Increase pressure within your burner’s design range.
- Make sure the tank isn’t frosting up and losing pressure.
- Consider a second burner if the chamber is large for one.
If you’re still planning or improving your forge, see building a gas bottle propane forge and burners and what is the best forge for beginners.