The short answer
It depends heavily on your forge. A small, well-insulated single-burner forge run at modest pressure can often go many hours, sometimes a full day of forging or more, on a 20 lb tank. A larger multi-burner forge, or any forge held at welding heat, can empty the same tank in just a few hours.
The most reliable way to know is to measure your own forge’s burn rate, which is easy to do with a bathroom or hanging scale.
What’s actually in a 20 lb tank
A “20 lb” tank, the common barbecue size, holds about 20 pounds of propane when full. That is roughly 4.7 gallons. Tanks are filled to about 80% of their volume to leave room for expansion, and the 20 lb figure already accounts for that.
In energy terms, that’s roughly 430,000 BTU of propane.
The empty weight of the tank is usually stamped on the collar as TW (tare weight), often around 17 lb. A full tank weighs about TW + 20 lb.
What controls how fast a forge burns propane
- Gas pressure and orifice size. These set how much propane flows. Higher pressure through the same orifice means more gas.
- Number of burners. Each burner adds its own consumption.
- Chamber size. A bigger chamber needs more fuel to reach and hold the same temperature.
- Insulation. Thin or damaged linings lose heat and need more gas to compensate. See lining a gas forge.
- Door openings. Large openings let heat escape.
- Target temperature. Holding welding heat uses noticeably more gas than ordinary forging. See how hot does a propane forge get.
- Burner tuning. A badly tuned burner wastes fuel. See how to tune a propane forge burner.
For a sense of scale, one smith reported in a forum thread that a sizeable ribbon-burner forge held at about 2,200°F used roughly 2 gallons of propane over a 3-hour session. At that rate, a 20 lb tank would last somewhere around 7 hours, but a smaller forge at lower heat can use far less.
Estimate your own run time
- Weigh the tank before you light the forge.
- Forge as you normally would and note how long the burner runs.
- Weigh the tank again after you shut off.
- Divide the pounds used by the hours run to get your burn rate in lb/hour.
- Divide 20 by your burn rate to estimate the run time of a full tank.
| Burn rate | Approx. run time on a full 20 lb tank |
|---|---|
| 0.5 lb/hour | About 40 hours |
| 1 lb/hour | About 20 hours |
| 2 lb/hour | About 10 hours |
| 3 lb/hour | About 6–7 hours |
| 4 lb/hour | About 5 hours |
In practice you’ll get somewhat less than the table suggests. Pressure drops as the tank empties and cools, so the last part of the tank is often hard to use at high flow.
Why the tank frosts up and the forge loses heat
Propane is stored as a liquid and boils into vapor inside the tank as you use it. That boiling absorbs heat from the tank and the liquid, so the tank gets colder. At high draw rates, a 20 lb tank can get cold enough to frost over. When that happens:
- The tank pressure drops
- Less gas reaches the burner
- The forge temperature falls, even though the regulator setting hasn’t changed
This is more noticeable in cold weather, with a nearly empty tank, and with high-consumption forges. The same forum poster mentioned above reported a small barbecue-size tank starting to freeze up within about 30–45 minutes at their forge’s draw.
Common ways smiths deal with it:
- Use a larger tank. Its larger liquid surface and mass can supply vapor faster.
- Connect two tanks together with a suitable manifold.
- Set the tank in a tub of water so it can pick up heat from the surroundings. Never use a flame, heat gun or other direct heat on a propane tank.
- Run at lower pressure when you don’t need full heat.
How to stretch a tank
- Keep the chamber only as big as your work needs, and block off unused openings with loose firebrick.
- Keep the lining in good repair.
- Turn the pressure down between heats, or while you’re thinking and setting up.
- Tune the burner for a clean flame instead of running extra-rich.
- Shut off the forge on long breaks instead of idling it.
When to move to a bigger tank
If you regularly run long sessions, forge-weld often, or see frost on a 20 lb tank partway through a session, a 40 lb or 100 lb tank may serve you better. They hold more fuel and generally resist freezing better, though they’re heavier to move and refill. If you have two 20 lb tanks, a manifold to run them together is another option.
Tank safety reminders
- Keep the tank upright, outside the forge area, and well away from the heat and hot work.
- Leak-test connections with soapy water each time you hook up.
- Close the tank valve when you’re finished, not just the burner valve.
- Store tanks outdoors, not in an enclosed shop or living space.
- Use an adjustable regulator and propane-rated hose. See our guide to building a gas bottle propane forge and burners for the full gas train.
If propane cost is a big concern, our guide to building a forge on a budget covers cheaper fuel options too.