Blacksmith History

Why are blacksmiths called black?

Blacksmiths are called black because iron was the 'black metal' and turns black with firescale when heated. Learn the history, the whitesmith contrast and myths.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. Reason 1: Iron Was the “Black Metal”
  3. Reason 2: Black Firescale
  4. Blacksmiths vs Whitesmiths
  5. What About Soot and Coal?
  6. Where “Smith” Comes From
  7. Other Kinds of Smith
  8. So Which Explanation Is Right?

The Short Answer

Blacksmiths are called “black” because they work with iron, which was traditionally known as the black metal. When iron is heated in a forge, its surface also quickly turns dark with a coating of black iron oxide called firescale. “Smith” is an old word for a skilled metalworker. So a blacksmith is, in plain terms, a worker of the black metal.

Other smiths who worked with lighter-colored metals, such as tin and silver, were sometimes called whitesmiths. The contrast helps explain why “black” was attached to ironworkers.

Reason 1: Iron Was the “Black Metal”

In older usage, metals were often grouped by color. Iron, which is dull gray to black in its raw or forged state, was considered a “black” metal. Bright, shiny metals such as silver and tin, and alloys such as pewter, were “white” metals.

This kind of color naming was common in the trades. Since the smith’s main material was iron, “black” became a natural label. Many dictionaries and historical sources give this as the main explanation.

Reason 2: Black Firescale

The second explanation comes from what actually happens in the forge. When iron or steel is heated in air, oxygen reacts with the hot surface and forms a layer of iron oxide. This layer, called firescale or forge scale, is dark gray to black. It flakes off under the hammer and builds up as black grit around the anvil.

Unless a smith filed, ground or polished the finished piece, most forged ironwork came out of the shop with a dark, scaly finish. Black scale, black iron and a dark, smoky workshop all reinforced the “black” image.

The two explanations fit together. Iron was “black” partly because forged iron so often looked black.

Blacksmiths vs Whitesmiths

The word whitesmith has been used in more than one way:

  • A worker in tin or tinplate, often called a tinsmith, who made cups, lanterns and other light goods
  • A worker in other “white” metals such as pewter
  • A smith who did finishing work on iron and steel, filing and polishing it bright rather than leaving it black from the forge, as in making locks, fine tools and polished fittings

In each case, the contrast was between rough, dark, heavy ironwork straight from the forge and bright, light or polished work. The blacksmith did the heavy hot work, and the whitesmith often did lighter or finer work, sometimes cold.

What About Soot and Coal?

A popular explanation is that blacksmiths were called “black” because they were covered in soot and coal dust. It’s true that smithing is dirty work, and smiths often finished the day blackened. But this isn’t usually given as the origin of the word. Plenty of other trades, such as charcoal burners and chimney sweeps, were just as dirty without being called “black-something.”

The idea probably helped the name feel fitting, but the metal itself is the more likely reason.

Where “Smith” Comes From

Smith comes from Old English smiþ, meaning a skilled craftsman, especially one who works metal. It traces back to a Proto-Germanic word with a similar meaning and has relatives in other Germanic languages, such as German Schmied and Old Norse smiðr.

Many people believe “smith” comes from “smite,” meaning to strike, since smiths spend all day hitting metal. The idea is appealing, but language historians generally don’t accept it as established. The connection between the two words is uncertain at best, and “smite” originally had a broader sense, closer to “to smear” or “to throw.”

For more on the word’s legacy, see why Smith is the most common surname, and for names of the workshop itself, see what a blacksmith’s workshop is called.

Other Kinds of Smith

“Smith” combined with other words to name many metal trades:

  • Goldsmith and silversmith: precious-metal workers
  • Tinsmith: tin and tinplate worker
  • Coppersmith: copper worker. The term redsmith has occasionally been used for copper and brass work too.
  • Locksmith: maker and repairer of locks
  • Gunsmith: maker and repairer of firearms
  • Bladesmith and swordsmith: makers of knives and swords
  • Arrowsmith: maker of arrowheads

Many of these survive as surnames today. Modern variations on the title are covered in What are modern day blacksmiths called?.

So Which Explanation Is Right?

Language rarely leaves a neat record of why a word was coined, so no one can say with full certainty. The most widely accepted view is that “black” refers to iron as the black metal, an idea strongly tied to the black scale forged iron carries. The soot explanation is better treated as a colorful extra than the real origin.

The complete guide to blacksmith history

Pioneer Blacksmiths: Facts About Life at the Frontier Forge
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →