The short answer
There’s no single figure for how much blacksmiths make, because “blacksmith” covers very different jobs. Salary aggregator websites that estimate pay from job postings have put the average for US blacksmith roles at roughly the high $30,000s to mid $40,000s a year. Treat that as a rough guide only.
In practice:
- Hobbyists usually earn little or nothing net, at least at first. Sales often just offset the cost of fuel, steel and tools.
- Employed shop smiths and fabricators typically earn wages similar to other skilled metal trades.
- Farriers often have the most consistent demand of any hand-forging trade, and experienced full-time farriers can do well, though running costs are high.
- Self-employed artists, architectural smiths and bladesmiths have the widest range, from struggling to very comfortable, depending largely on business skills and reputation.
Why blacksmith salary figures are unreliable
Before relying on any number you find online, keep in mind:
- Very few people are employed with the job title “blacksmith.” Most hand-forging professionals are self-employed, so they don’t show up in job-posting data.
- Official statistics don’t track hand blacksmiths separately. In the US, government occupational data groups forging workers mainly under industrial categories like forging machine operators. That’s a different job from forging by hand.
- Aggregator data mixes very different roles. A “blacksmith” posting might be for an industrial forge operator, a fabrication shop, a museum interpreter or a farm maintenance job.
- Self-employed income isn’t the same as a salary. A smith who invoices a lot may still net much less after materials, fuel, equipment, insurance and taxes.
So salary figures are a starting point at best, not a prediction of what you’d earn.
Pay by type of blacksmithing work
Employed shop smiths and fabricators
Some ornamental ironwork shops, fabrication businesses and restoration companies employ smiths. Pay for these roles is generally in line with other skilled metal trades in the area, such as welders and fabricators. Welding and fabrication skills often increase your employability, because most of these shops mix forging with modern fabrication.
Farriers
Farriery is the most steadily employed branch of hand forging, because horses still need their hooves trimmed and shod. Most farriers are self-employed and charge per horse or per visit. Trade surveys, including those published by American Farriers Journal, have generally shown that experienced full-time farriers can earn a solid income. But gross revenue isn’t take-home pay: a farrier pays for the truck, fuel, tools, shoes and nails, insurance and sometimes an assistant. It’s also very physically demanding work, which affects how many horses you can shoe and for how many years.
Industrial forging
Factory forging, where parts are made with large power hammers, presses and dies, is a very different job from hand blacksmithing, though it uses the same material. These are employed positions with regular wages and often benefits. Pay varies by employer, region, skill level and shift.
Bladesmiths and knifemakers
Handmade knives can sell well, and well-known makers command premium prices. But knifemaking is competitive. Most bladesmiths sell part-time alongside other work, and building a reputation takes time. Credentials such as American Bladesmith Society ratings, a recognizable maker’s mark, a good online presence and attending knife shows all help.
Architectural and artist blacksmiths
Smiths who make gates, railings, lighting, custom hardware and sculpture can earn well on commissions, especially for high-end residential and commercial projects. Income tends to be uneven, though: large jobs come in irregularly, and a lot of time goes into design, client meetings, quoting and installation. Many architectural smiths combine forged work with fabrication and welding to keep the shop busy.
Teaching
Teaching classes is an important income stream for many working smiths, because demand from beginners is strong. Class fees bring in money, and a teaching schedule can smooth out the irregular income from commissions. To see what students pay, read how much it costs to learn blacksmithing.
Can hobby blacksmiths make money?
Some do, especially once their skills are solid. But it’s easy to overestimate. Here’s an illustrative example, not real data, to show the economics:
Suppose you make simple forged bottle openers. Each one takes some time at the forge plus finishing, uses a small amount of steel and fuel, and you sell them at a craft fair. On paper, the margin per piece over materials can look reasonable. But once you count:
- the time spent forging, finishing and packaging
- the fair’s booth fee and travel
- unsold stock
- wear on tools and abrasives
- the cost of your equipment, which may take years of sales to pay back
the effective hourly rate is often low, sometimes below minimum wage. Most hobbyists who sell find that it pays for the hobby rather than providing an income.
Ways hobbyists improve the numbers:
- Make items that sell well and can be made efficiently in batches, such as hooks, bottle openers and fire tools.
- Price for your time, not just materials.
- Take commissions for custom pieces, which can command higher prices.
- Build a following online and through repeat customers.
If you sell regularly, check how your country or state treats hobby versus business income for tax purposes.
What affects earnings
- Specialty: farriery and architectural work generally offer more consistent paid work than general decorative forging.
- Location: demand and prices vary a lot between regions and between urban and rural areas.
- Skill and reputation: experienced smiths with a recognizable style and a portfolio can charge more.
- Business skills: marketing, pricing, quoting and customer service often matter as much as forging ability.
- Related skills: welding, fabrication, design and machining widen the work you can take on.
- Employment type: employed roles offer stability, while self-employment offers more upside and more risk.
Costs that eat into income
Self-employed smiths need to account for:
- Equipment such as forges, anvils, power hammers, grinders and welders, plus maintenance
- Shop rent or property costs, utilities and fuel
- Materials and consumables
- Insurance, including liability insurance
- Vehicle costs for installations or mobile farrier work
- Marketing, websites, booth fees and selling platform fees
- Taxes, and in the US the self-employment portion of payroll taxes
Ways working smiths add income
Many full-time smiths combine several income streams:
- Commissions and custom work
- Teaching classes and private lessons
- Selling at craft fairs, markets and online
- Demonstrations at events and historic sites
- Repair and restoration work
- Making and selling tools to other smiths
- Writing or making educational videos
Bottom line
Blacksmithing can provide a living, but it rarely comes from forging alone. Farriery is the most reliable route to steady income. Architectural work, knives and teaching can pay well for skilled smiths with good business sense. For most hobbyists, selling work is a way to fund the hobby rather than a primary income. Historically, too, most smiths were secure but rarely rich.
For a wider view of where the work is, see is blacksmithing a dead trade?, and if you’re considering learning under a working smith, read our guide to blacksmithing apprenticeships in the USA.