Riveting is one of the oldest ways to join iron, and it’s still one of the most useful for a blacksmith. It needs no welder, it looks right on traditional work, and it allows moving joints such as hinges and tongs. This guide covers how rivets work, how to size and set them, and how to deal with the common problems.
How a Rivet Works
A rivet is a short metal pin with a head on one end. It passes through aligned holes in the pieces being joined. Then the plain end is hammered to form a second head, so the parts are clamped between the two heads.
Two things make a riveted joint strong:
- The rivet fills the hole. When the shank is upset, it swells to fill the hole snugly, so the parts can’t slide relative to each other. In most structural joints the rivet takes load in shear, across its body.
- Hot rivets shrink as they cool. A rivet set hot contracts as it cools, pulling the two heads toward each other. This draws the joint tight, which is a big reason blacksmiths often prefer hot riveting for fixed joints.
For a moving joint, such as a hinge or a pair of tongs, the goal is different. The rivet should hold the parts together but still let them pivot.
Hot Riveting vs Cold Riveting
- Hot riveting: the rivet is heated to a bright orange to yellow, then set. It’s easier to upset, forms full heads with less force, and tightens the joint as it cools. It’s best for structural and decorative fixed joints, and for thicker rivets.
- Cold riveting: the rivet is set at room temperature. It’s simpler for small rivets, often around 1/8” or less, and for moving joints where you don’t want the extra tightening from shrinkage. It needs more hammer blows and is harder with larger diameters.
Many smiths set structural rivets hot. For pivoting joints they set them cold or only warm, or they set them hot and then work the joint loose while it’s still warm.
Tools for Riveting
- Ball-peen hammer: the ball is useful for spreading and rounding the rivet head.
- Rivet set (or snap): a punch with a cup-shaped end matching the head shape. It’s used to finish a clean, round head.
- Bolster, dolly or backing set: a cupped support under the existing head, so it isn’t flattened while you form the other. A rivet set held in a vise, or a cupped hole in a block, works well.
- Drill or punch: for making the holes. Punching hot steel is traditional. Drilling is simpler and more precise.
- Drift or tapered pin: for lining up holes before you insert the rivet.
- Clamps or a vise: to hold the parts tight together while riveting.
- Rivets: commercial mild steel rivets, or ones you make yourself.
Sizing Holes and Rivet Length
Hole size: the hole should be just large enough for the rivet to slip in without forcing it. Too tight and the rivet won’t go in, especially hot. Too loose and the shank may bend instead of upsetting cleanly, and the joint will be weaker.
Shank length: the shank should stick out past the work enough to form the new head. A common rule of thumb for a round head is to leave about 1 1/2 times the rivet’s diameter sticking out. For example, leave about 3/8” for a 1/4” rivet. Treat this as a starting point and adjust after a test joint. Too little and the head will be small and weak. Too much and the shank tends to bend over.
For flush rivets (below), you need less protrusion, just enough to fill the countersink.
How to Set a Hot Round-Head Rivet
- Prepare the parts. Mark, drill or punch the holes, and deburr them. Clamp the parts together with the holes aligned. A drift through the holes helps line them up.
- Trim the rivet. Cut the rivet so the shank will stick out about 1 1/2 times its diameter past the work.
- Heat the rivet. Bring it to a bright orange or yellow. Small rivets lose heat very quickly, so have everything ready before you pull it from the fire.
- Insert it. Drop the hot rivet into the hole with tongs. Set the existing head into a cupped bolster or rivet set held in the vise, so it keeps its round shape.
- Upset the shank. Hit the end of the shank squarely with the flat face of the hammer a few times. This swells it to fill the hole and pulls the parts together.
- Form the head. Use the ball of a ball-peen hammer, or angled blows around the edge, to dome the head.
- Finish with the rivet set. Place the cupped rivet set over the head and strike it a few times to form a neat, round head.
- Let it cool. As it cools, the rivet shrinks and pulls the joint tighter.
At larger scales, riveting was often a two-person job, with one person holding the work and backing set and another striking. Our article on why blacksmiths double tap the anvil touches on how smiths and strikers worked together.
Flush (Countersunk) Rivets
Sometimes a rivet head shouldn’t show, for example on a flat surface or where the parts need to slide past each other.
- Countersink the hole on the side where the head should be flush, using a countersink bit or a tapered punch.
- Leave less shank sticking out, just enough to fill the countersink.
- Upset the shank into the countersink with the flat face of the hammer.
- File or grind it flush, if needed.
Done well, the rivet nearly disappears.
Making Your Own Rivets
You can make rivets from round mild steel bar, the same way you’d forge a nail head:
- Cut a piece of round bar a little longer than the rivet you need.
- Heat one end and drop the bar into a rivet header: a plate with a hole matching the rivet’s diameter, sized so the hot end stands proud.
- Upset the protruding end into a head with the hammer, then finish it with a rivet set for a round head.
- Knock the rivet out of the header and trim it to length when you’re ready to use it.
Homemade rivets are useful when you need an unusual size or want heads with a hand-forged look.
Tenons: Rivets Forged From the Workpiece
A tenon is a reduced end on a bar that passes through a hole in another piece and is peened over, just like a rivet. The difference is that it’s forged from the workpiece itself. Tenons are common in railings, gates and decorative work, and they make a strong, traditional joint.
To make one, forge a shoulder near the bar end and reduce the end to the tenon size. Then pass it through the mating hole and peen it over, hot or cold. Our guide on how to forge a metal rose uses a peened tenon to hold the petals on the stem.
Riveting vs Collars and Welding
- Rivets: strong, traditional and visible. They can pivot, and they need holes.
- Collars: a wrapped band of steel that binds two or more bars together. Collars are mainly decorative and are good for scrollwork clusters. See blacksmith art and design for more on traditional joinery.
- Forge welding: joins pieces into one with no fastener. It’s demanding, but invisible when done well.
- Arc welding: fast and strong, but it often looks out of place on traditional forged work unless cleaned up carefully.
Many smiths mix these methods, picking whichever suits the joint and the look they want.
How to Drill Out a Rivet
Mistakes happen, and a bad rivet may need to come out:
- Flatten the head. Grind or file the head flat so a drill bit won’t wander.
- Center punch it. Mark the center of the head.
- Drill. Use a sharp high-speed steel (HSS) bit, or a cobalt bit for harder material, slightly smaller than the rivet’s shank. Drill only through the depth of the head.
- Pop the head off. Use a cold chisel or snap the head off with a punch in the hole.
- Drive out the shank. Use a pin punch slightly smaller than the hole.
For mild steel rivets, a sharp HSS bit is usually enough. The key is a sharp bit, light oil and moderate speed, not the most expensive bit. Cobalt bits help if the rivets or the parts are harder.
Common Problems
- The shank bent over. Too much shank, a loose hole, or blows that weren’t square. Trim the shank shorter and start with straight, flat blows.
- The joint is loose. The hole was too big, or the rivet didn’t upset enough before the head was formed. Hot riveting usually helps.
- The head is off-center. The rivet set or hammer wasn’t centered. Check alignment before each blow.
- The original head got flattened. It wasn’t supported in a cupped bolster or rivet set. Always back it up.
- Hammer marks on the work. Miss-hits damaged the surface around the rivet. A rivet set gives more control near the work.
For more on the basic hammer moves involved, see How do you forge metal?. For riveted projects to try, see the fire poker guide, which suggests riveted fire tool sets, and our blacksmith project plans for beginners.