Projects

When did they stop using iron nails?

Iron nails gave way to steel from the 1880s, and wire nails took over by around 1900. Here's how nails went from hand-forged iron to machine-made steel.

On this page
  1. The Short Answer
  2. Hand-Wrought Iron Nails
  3. Machine-Cut Nails
  4. From Iron to Steel
  5. Wire Nails Take Over
  6. Why Steel Replaced Iron
  7. Are Iron Nails Still Made?
  8. Using Nails to Date a Building (With Caveats)

The Short Answer

Iron nails weren’t dropped all at once. They were phased out over the second half of the nineteenth century, and the timing varied from country to country. Roughly:

  • Until around 1800, most nails were hand-forged from wrought iron by smiths and specialist nailers.
  • From the late 1700s through most of the 1800s, machine-cut nails, sliced from iron plate, took over much of the market, especially in the United States.
  • From about the 1880s, cut nails were increasingly made from steel instead of iron.
  • By around 1900, steel wire nails, the round-shank nails still used today, had overtaken cut nails in the United States. They became widespread in Britain in the early twentieth century.

So for everyday building, iron nails had mostly given way to steel by the start of the twentieth century. Hand-forged nails and cut nails are still made today, but only for specialist uses.

There are really two separate changes here. One is how nails were made: by hand, then cut by machine, then made from wire. The other is what they were made of: wrought iron, then steel. They overlapped, which is why answers to this question often seem to disagree.

Hand-Wrought Iron Nails

Iron nails go back a very long way. The Romans used them in huge numbers. A well-known hoard of iron nails was buried at the Roman fortress of Inchtuthil in Scotland when it was abandoned in the late first century AD.

For most of history, a nail was made one at a time. The nailer drew out a tapered point on the end of an iron rod, cut it to length, and formed a head in a nail header. Our guide to forging nails shows that process, which hasn’t changed much. Shanks were typically square in section, and heads were often the faceted “rose head” style.

Nail making grew into a large trade in its own right. In parts of Britain it was a cottage industry, with families working small forges at home and paid by the piece. Slitting mills, which cut iron bars into rods, made the nailer’s raw material cheaper and more uniform from around the late sixteenth century onward in England. But the nails themselves were still made by hand.

The iron itself came from a charcoal-fired process. If you’re curious how smiths of the time got iron hot enough to work, see how medieval forges got hot enough.

Machine-Cut Nails

In the late eighteenth century, inventors, many of them in the United States, developed machines that sheared tapered nail blanks from strips of iron plate. Early cut nails often still had their heads finished by hand. Later machines cut and headed nails in one process.

Cut nails were much faster and cheaper to produce than hand-forged ones. During the first half of the nineteenth century they became the standard building nail in America. A cut nail is easy to recognize: it’s rectangular in section, tapers on two faces only, and has a blunt tip. It’s still made today for restoration work and some masonry and flooring uses.

From Iron to Steel

Through most of the nineteenth century, cut nails were made of wrought iron. That changed once steel became cheap. The Bessemer process and the open-hearth process made steel in large quantities from the 1860s and 1870s onward. During the 1880s nail makers increasingly switched from iron to steel, which was consistent, strong and increasingly cheaper. This is effectively when iron nails stopped being the everyday standard.

Wire Nails Take Over

Wire nails are made by cutting steel wire to length, forming a head and pressing a point, all by machine and at high speed. They had existed earlier in Europe, but in the late nineteenth century cheap steel wire and automatic machines made them very inexpensive.

In the United States, wire nails overtook cut nails in production around the 1890s. By the early twentieth century they dominated general construction. In Britain, wire nails had become the norm in the early 1900s. The round wire nail is still the standard nail almost everywhere.

Why Steel Replaced Iron

A few factors came together:

  • Cost. Mass-produced steel became cheaper than wrought iron, which needed a lot of skilled labor to make.
  • Consistency. Steel made in large batches had more uniform properties than wrought iron, which contains slag inclusions.
  • Manufacturing. Steel could be drawn into wire and fed through automatic machines with almost no hand work.
  • Strength. Steel nails could be made thinner for the same holding job, which saved material and reduced splitting in some woods.

Are Iron Nails Still Made?

Yes, but in small numbers and for particular purposes:

  • Blacksmiths still forge nails by hand for restoration, reproduction furniture and decorative hardware, and as a practice exercise.
  • Restoration suppliers sell hand-forged and cut nails for historic buildings, boats and furniture.

Note that most “hand-forged iron nails” sold today are forged from modern mild steel. True wrought iron is no longer produced commercially in any quantity. Britain’s last commercial wrought iron works closed in the 1970s. Wrought iron needed for conservation work is often reclaimed and reworked from old stock.

Using Nails to Date a Building (With Caveats)

Nails are a popular dating clue in old buildings. A commonly used rule of thumb:

  • Hand-wrought nails suggest work from before about 1800.
  • Cut nails suggest roughly 1800 to the late 1800s or early 1900s.
  • Wire nails suggest the late 1800s onward.

Use this with care. Dates differed between regions and countries, and rural builders often kept using older nails for years after new ones appeared. Buildings were repaired, extended and refitted, and nails were sometimes reused. Cut nails stayed in use for flooring and some trim long after wire nails took over. Nails are best treated as one piece of evidence alongside others, such as saw marks, construction methods and documents.

For a hands-on look at the craft behind the oldest nails, see our guide to forging nails, or browse our beginner blacksmith project plans.

The complete guide to projects

Blacksmith Project Plans for Beginners
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →