Anvils and Tools

Making Chisels from Old Files

How to turn old files into cold chisels or wood chisels: testing the steel, annealing, grinding or forging, hardening, tempering colours and safety tips.

On this page
  1. Why files make good chisel steel
  2. Safety first: hardened files are brittle
  3. Check the file is worth using
  4. Choose your chisel type
  5. Route 1: stock removal (no forge)
  6. Route 2: forging the chisel
  7. Hardening
  8. Tempering
  9. Sharpening and finishing
  10. Quick answers to common chisel questions

Why files make good chisel steel

Files are made from high-carbon steel and hardened so their teeth can cut other metals. That same steel, reshaped and given a suitable temper, makes a good chisel edge. Worn files are cheap or free at flea markets and in old toolboxes, so they’re a popular first source of tool steel for new smiths. Turning them into chisels is a classic poorboy blacksmithing project.

There are two broad routes. You can grind the chisel to shape without a forge (stock removal), or you can forge it hot and then finish it. Both end in the same heat treatment.

Safety first: hardened files are brittle

A file as it comes from the factory is very hard and quite brittle. That’s fine for filing, but it means:

  • Never strike a hardened file with a hammer, or use one as a pry bar or punch. It can snap and throw sharp fragments.
  • Wear impact-rated eye protection whenever you grind, forge or test file steel.
  • Grinding produces hot sparks and fine dust. Clear away flammables and use a dust mask or respirator.
  • Quenching in oil can flare. Use a metal container with a lid nearby, work away from anything flammable, and keep a suitable fire extinguisher at hand.

Check the file is worth using

Not every file is solid high-carbon steel. Some cheaper modern files are believed to be made from lower-carbon steel with only a hardened surface layer, which won’t harden properly once you grind through it. Ways to check:

  • Prefer older files from established makers. Many smiths favour older files with a known brand.
  • Spark test. Grind a small spot through the surface. High-carbon steel throws bright, bushy sparks with many bursts or forks. Low-carbon steel gives longer, plainer streaks. It helps to compare against a known piece of mild steel.
  • Hardening test. Heat a small offcut to the hardening temperature (see below), quench it, then try another file on it. If the file skates off without biting, the steel hardened.

Choose your chisel type

Decide what you’re making before you start, because it affects the shape and temper.

Cold chisels for metal. These are struck with a hammer to cut or shear cold metal. The four traditional types are:

  1. Flat chisel. The general-purpose straight edge.
  2. Cape chisel. A narrow edge for cutting grooves and keyways.
  3. Round-nose (gouge) chisel. For cutting rounded grooves.
  4. Diamond-point chisel. For cutting V-grooves and sharp corners.

Wood chisels. These are pushed or lightly tapped with a mallet to pare and chop wood. They’re thinner, with a finer edge, and are usually left harder than cold chisels.

If you’re asked “the four main types of chisels”, the answer depends on the context. The list above is the classic set of cold chisels. Woodworking has its own categories, such as bench, mortise and paring chisels.

Route 1: stock removal (no forge)

This route suits wood chisels and small cold chisels.

  1. Soften the file first. A fully hard file is hard to grind without overheating it, and it’s brittle. Many makers anneal it: heat it until it’s no longer attracted to a magnet, then let it cool very slowly, for example buried in wood ash or vermiculite, or left in a dying forge. Annealed steel can be cut, filed and drilled.
  2. Grind off the teeth where the bevel and the flat back will be. Leftover teeth near the edge make it hard to sharpen and can act as stress points.
  3. Grind the shape and bevel. Keep the edge slightly thick at this stage, so it doesn’t overheat or warp during hardening. Grind or file it to final sharpness after heat treatment.
  4. Shape the struck or handle end. Grind a slight chamfer on a cold chisel’s struck end, or a tang for a wooden handle on a wood chisel.

Then move on to hardening.

Route 2: forging the chisel

Forging lets you thicken the struck end, change the profile and draw a long taper.

  1. Grind off the teeth in the area you’ll forge. Forging over teeth can fold them into the surface.
  2. Forge at a good, bright heat. File steel doesn’t like being hammered too cold, which risks cracks. Reheat as soon as the colour drops to a dull red.
  3. Don’t overheat it either. Steel that’s sparking or very bright in the fire is being burned and will be weakened.
  4. Draw out the taper and bevel, and leave some thickness at the edge for final grinding.
  5. Normalise. Heat the chisel evenly to just past non-magnetic and let it cool in still air. Doing this two or three times helps relieve stress from forging.

Hardening

  1. Heat the cutting end evenly to a little past the point where a magnet no longer sticks. Heat a generous length of the end, not just the very tip.
  2. Quench it edge-first into the quenchant, moving it up and down rather than swirling.
    • Warm oil (a commercial quench oil, or vegetable oil, which many hobbyists use) is less likely to crack the steel. It may not fully harden every file steel.
    • Water or brine is a more aggressive quench. It hardens plain carbon steels well but carries a higher risk of cracking.
  3. Test the edge with a file. It should skate off. If it bites easily, the quench didn’t harden it.

A hardened chisel that hasn’t been tempered is too brittle to use. Temper it promptly.

Tempering

Tempering trades a little hardness for toughness. Polish the hardened area to bright metal so you can see the oxide colours, then heat gently. Use a kitchen oven, a torch played on the thick part so the colour runs toward the edge, or the residual heat of a bar.

Approximate temper colours:

Colour on bright steel Approximate temperature Typical use
Pale straw about 400°F (about 205°C) Hard edges: some wood chisels, scrapers
Dark straw about 440°F (about 225°C) Wood chisels, punches
Brown/bronze about 500°F (about 260°C) Cold chisel edges for general use
Purple about 530°F (about 275°C) Tougher cold chisels
Blue about 570°F+ (about 300°C+) Struck ends, springs

These are rough guides. Colours depend on lighting and on how long the steel is held at temperature. For cold chisels, a common approach is a brownish-to-purple edge, with the struck end drawn softer, to blue or beyond, so it deforms rather than chipping when hit. For wood chisels, a straw edge is typical. Test your result. If the edge chips, temper a little more. If it rolls or dents, it may be too soft.

Sharpening and finishing

  • Cold chisels usually get a fairly blunt edge, something in the region of 60 degrees included, which stands up to hammering. Sharpen with a file or grinder, and cool the edge often so you don’t draw the temper.
  • Wood chisels need a flat, polished back and a much finer bevel, typically in the region of 25 to 30 degrees. Hone them on stones.
  • Dress the struck end of cold chisels regularly. A mushroomed head can throw chips when struck. Grind it back to a slight chamfer.

Fit wood chisels with a wooden handle and, if they’ll be struck, a ferrule. Use a proper engineer’s or club hammer for cold chisels, not your forging hammer’s best face. Our hammer guide explains the difference.

Once you’ve done one file, you have the skills for related projects. A hot cut hardy tool and a steel hand stamp both rely on the same hardening and tempering steps.

Quick answers to common chisel questions

How do you make a chisel? Shape high-carbon steel to the profile you need, harden it by heating and quenching, temper it to the toughness the job needs, then sharpen. The steps above apply to most simple chisels.

Can I use my hammer drill as a chisel? Only if the tool has a dedicated hammer-only or chisel mode and accepts chisel bits, as many rotary hammers do. A standard hammer drill is designed to drill with a hammering action, not to chisel, so check the manufacturer’s instructions.

Why are Japanese chisels so good? Traditional Japanese chisels are usually laminated. A thin layer of very hard steel forms the cutting edge, backed by softer iron or steel. That lets the edge be hardened more than a single-steel chisel could safely be, while the softer backing absorbs shock and makes the flat back easier to sharpen. A file chisel is a simpler, single-steel tool, but it can still be a very capable edge.

For the rest of the beginner’s tool set, see our essential blacksmithing kit guide.

The complete guide to anvils and tools

Blacksmithing Tools of the Trade: The Beginner's Essential Kit
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →