What “poorboy” means in blacksmithing
In hobby blacksmithing, a “poorboy” (or “poor boy”) tool is improvised, homemade or salvaged gear that does the job of an expensive purpose-built tool. Think of a block of scrap steel instead of an anvil, a brake drum instead of a commercial forge, or locking pliers welded to bar stock instead of bought tongs.
The idea has long circulated among hobby smiths. One well-known example was Ken Scharabok, a Tennessee smith who for years sold affordable, simple tools for beginners under the name Poor Boy Blacksmith Tools. In a profile in The Fabricator, he was clear they were meant for amateurs, not professional hard service. That’s a good way to think about all poorboy gear: it gets you forging now, and you can upgrade the pieces that hold you back later.
Improvised anvils
The anvil is usually the biggest expense in blacksmithing. That makes it the first place people look to improvise. The key principle is that mass directly under the hammer matters most. A compact chunk of steel stood upright often works better than a flat, wide piece of the same weight.
Heavy steel blocks and drops
Solid steel is the best improvised anvil. Look for:
- Large round or square bar offcuts (“drops”) from a steel supplier or machine shop
- Forklift tine sections
- Large shaft ends, such as heavy axles or press parts
- Thick steel plate stacked and secured, though a single solid piece is better
Stand it on end so the hammer strikes into the long axis, and mount it firmly in a stump or bucket of sand. A face of around 3 to 4 inches across is enough for a lot of beginner work. Most of these blocks are unhardened mild or medium-carbon steel, so they’ll mark up more than a hardened anvil face, but they still work.
Railroad track
Rail is the classic improvised anvil. Many people mount a section flat, so the top of the rail is the working face. That’s convenient, but most of the metal isn’t under the hammer. Standing a short section on end puts far more mass directly under the blow and generally works noticeably better, although the face is small.
Rail and track parts belong to the railway. Only use pieces you’ve obtained legally, from scrap yards, salvage sellers or with permission. Never take them from active or abandoned lines.
Sledgehammer heads and other small options
A sledgehammer head set face-up in a stump makes a small but usable anvil for light work like hooks and small scrolls. It’s a good stopgap while you look for something bigger. Truly small improvised anvils tend to bounce and walk, so mount them solidly.
Avoid the very cheap cast iron “anvils” sold in hardware stores. A block of scrap steel usually outperforms them. Our anvil review explains why. For weight guidance, see how heavy should a blacksmith anvil be?
Improvised forges
Two classic shoestring designs:
- Brake drum forge. An old cast iron brake drum serves as a fire pot for coal or charcoal, with a pipe underneath carrying air from a blower or hair dryer. It’s simple, cheap and widely built.
- Small insulated gas forge. A steel container lined with refractory insulation, heated by a propane burner. There are many build guides around. Follow one from a reputable source, because burner design and ventilation both matter.
A “two-brick forge” heated with a hand-held propane torch can get small pieces of thin stock hot enough to bend. It’s very limited, but it’s a cheap way to try the basics.
Things to keep in mind with any homemade forge:
- Don’t use galvanised (zinc-coated) parts anywhere they’ll get hot. Heated zinc gives off fumes that can make you ill.
- Ventilate. Gas and solid-fuel forges both produce carbon monoxide. Work outdoors or in a well-ventilated space, and consider a CO alarm.
- Keep it stable and away from flammables. A forge on an unsteady stand is a fire risk.
Tongs on the cheap
Ways to hold hot steel without buying a full set of tongs:
- Forge on the end of a long bar and hold the cold end by hand, then cut the piece off. This works for many small projects and costs nothing.
- Locking pliers can hold small work for brief periods. Some smiths weld bar stock to them for extra reach. They aren’t designed for forging heat and can lose their grip or temper, so treat them as temporary.
- Simple homemade tongs from flat bar or rivet-joined pieces are a common early project. Tong blanks, sold as pre-forged halves you finish yourself, are a cheaper middle ground.
Our tongs guide for beginners explains which shapes to aim for.
Hammers from the flea market
Old hammers turn up cheaply at flea markets, farm sales and second-hand tool stalls. A cross peen or ball peen of around 2 to 2.5 pounds, with the face dressed to a slight dome and the edges rounded on a grinder, makes a perfectly good forging hammer. Check the head isn’t cracked or badly mushroomed, and fit a sound handle. See our guide to choosing your first blacksmith hammer.
Hardy tools, vises and the rest
- Hardy tools. Simple ones like a bending fork can be made from square bar that fits your hardy hole. If your improvised anvil has no hardy hole, many of the same jobs can be done with tools clamped in a vise. See hardy tools explained.
- Chisels and punches. Old files, coil springs and other salvaged high-carbon steel can become punches and chisels. Our guide to making chisels from old files walks through it.
- Vise. Second-hand leg vises turn up at farm and estate sales. Until you find one, a sturdy bench vise can handle light bending, though cast iron vises can crack if hammered heavily.
- Quench bucket. Any sturdy metal bucket works.
- Stand. A hardwood stump, a timber stack or a sand-filled container all work. See how to make an anvil stand.
Improvised stock: what to forge
New mild steel bar from a steel supplier is inexpensive, predictable and the best material to learn on. Salvaged steel is tempting, but its composition is often unknown. That doesn’t matter much for decorative work. It can matter a lot for tools and blades that need heat treating. Treat salvaged steel as an experiment, and test a piece before relying on it.
What not to cut corners on
Improvising tools is part of the tradition. Improvising safety is not. Spend money on:
- Impact-rated safety glasses and hearing protection
- Suitable natural-fibre clothing and sturdy boots
- A fire extinguisher
- Ventilation for your forge
And don’t heat galvanised, plated or painted metal of unknown origin without removing the coating first, outdoors and away from the forge.
When to upgrade
Poorboy gear is a starting point. Most smiths upgrade the piece that’s holding them back the most, and that’s usually the anvil, followed by a properly sized forge and better tongs. Our article on whether blacksmithing is a cheap hobby looks at where the money tends to go. Our essential blacksmithing kit guide suggests a sensible buying order.