Anvils and Tools

Choosing Your First Blacksmith Hammer: Weight, Shape and Handle

How to choose your first blacksmith hammer: a sensible weight, cross peen vs rounding hammer, face shape, dressing a cheap hammer, handles and grip basics.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Weight: why lighter is often better at first
  3. Head shapes
  4. The face matters more than the brand
  5. Dressing a hardware-store hammer
  6. Handles: length, shape and material
  7. Grip and swing basics
  8. Hammers to avoid
  9. When to add a second hammer

The short answer

For most beginners, a good first forging hammer is a cross peen or rounding hammer weighing around 2 to 2.5 pounds (roughly 900 g to 1.1 kg). It should have a slightly domed face with rounded edges and a comfortable wooden handle around 14 inches (35 cm) long. Larger, stronger people may be comfortable up to about 3 pounds. Smaller people or those with joint concerns may prefer something lighter.

What matters most is that you can swing it accurately for a whole session without strain. Accuracy moves more metal than raw weight does.

Weight: why lighter is often better at first

It’s tempting to buy a heavy hammer, thinking it will move metal faster. In practice, beginners using hammers that are too heavy tend to:

  • Tire quickly and lose accuracy
  • Leave hammer marks and dents from tilted blows
  • Grip too tightly, which can strain the wrist, elbow and shoulder

A moderate hammer lets you build accuracy and rhythm first. You can always add a heavier hammer later for bigger stock. If you notice persistent pain in your wrist, elbow or shoulder, ease off and look at your hammer weight, grip and anvil height. If it continues, get it checked by a medical professional.

Your hammer and anvil also go together. An old rule of thumb suggests an anvil of around 50 times the hammer’s weight. See how heavy a blacksmith anvil should be.

Head shapes

Cross peen

The classic blacksmith’s hammer. It has a flat (slightly domed) face on one side and a wedge-shaped peen running across the handle on the other. The face does general forging. The peen spreads metal in one direction, which is useful for drawing out quickly, fullering and texture. It’s a safe all-round first choice.

Rounding hammer

A rounding hammer has one fairly flat face and one strongly rounded face. It came from farriery and has become very popular among blacksmiths. The rounded face pushes metal quickly and can be used much like a peen, while the flat face smooths. Many beginners find it versatile.

Straight peen

This is like a cross peen, but the peen runs parallel to the handle. It spreads metal sideways rather than lengthwise. It’s useful, but usually a second or third hammer.

Ball peen

A ball peen hammer has a flat face and a hemispherical ball. They’re common in hardware stores and workshops, and a heavier ball peen of around 24 to 32 ounces can make a perfectly usable starter forging hammer once dressed. Many lighter ball peens are too small for most forging.

Sledges and drilling hammers

Short-handled drilling (lump) hammers of around 2 to 4 pounds are good for striking punches, chisels and stamps, which saves the face of your forging hammer. Full sledges are used by a striker working with a smith, and aren’t a beginner’s main tool.

The face matters more than the brand

The shape of the striking face affects your work more than the logo on the side. A good forging face:

  • Is slightly domed (crowned), so the edge of the face doesn’t dig in if you strike at a small angle
  • Has rounded edges, which avoid sharp dents and cold shuts in the work
  • Is smooth and polished. Marks on the hammer transfer to the work

New forging hammers from specialist makers usually come this way. General-purpose hammers often don’t.

Dressing a hardware-store hammer

You can turn an ordinary hammer into a good forging hammer:

  1. Grind a gentle dome on the face, keeping the centre highest.
  2. Round the edges of the face to a generous radius.
  3. Smooth and polish the face, working up through finer abrasives.
  4. Soften the peen edges if they’re sharp.
  5. Keep the head cool while grinding. Dip it in water often. Overheating can soften the hardened face.

Wear eye protection, and keep the grinder’s sparks away from flammables. Old hammers from flea markets are ideal for this. See our guide to poorboy blacksmith tools.

Handles: length, shape and material

  • Material. Wood, typically hickory or ash, is the traditional choice. It absorbs some shock and can be shaped to suit you. Fibreglass and steel handles are tougher but can transmit more vibration.
  • Length. Around 12 to 16 inches (30 to 40 cm) is typical. Many smiths shorten handles to suit their grip. A handle that’s too long tends to get choked up on anyway.
  • Shape. An oval or slightly octagonal cross-section helps you feel the hammer’s orientation without looking, so the face lands flat.
  • Fit. The head should be tight, wedged securely and checked often. A loose head can fly off.

Grip and swing basics

  • Hold the handle loosely, toward the end, with a relaxed hand. A death grip wastes energy and strains the forearm.
  • Let the hammer’s weight do the work. Lift, then let it fall with control.
  • Swing from the shoulder and elbow, keeping the wrist fairly neutral.
  • Watch the work, not the hammer.
  • Set your anvil at the right height, typically around knuckle height when your arms hang at your sides. See our guide to making an anvil stand.
  • Never strike the bare anvil face hard with your hammer. Hardened steel on hardened steel can chip and throw fragments.

Good hammer control is one of the foundation skills of a blacksmith, and it improves quickly with practice.

Hammers to avoid

  • Claw hammers. They’re often too light, the faces may not suit forging, and the claws get in the way.
  • Very heavy hammers as a first choice. Wait until you know what you need.
  • Hammers with cracked, chipped or badly mushroomed heads. Fragments can break off.
  • Your forging hammer as a striking tool for chisels and punches. Use a drilling hammer instead. See making chisels from old files for more on struck tools.

When to add a second hammer

After a few months, many smiths add:

  • A heavier hammer, perhaps 3 to 4 pounds, for larger stock
  • A lighter hammer for fine finishing work
  • A drilling hammer for striking tools
  • A different peen, for example a straight peen or rounding hammer to complement a cross peen

With a hammer and a few pairs of tongs, you have the core of a working kit. Our essential blacksmithing tools guide covers the rest.

The complete guide to anvils and tools

Blacksmithing Tools of the Trade: The Beginner's Essential Kit
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →