The short answer
Anvils are expensive because a good one is a large, heavy piece of high-quality steel that has to be carefully heat treated, made in small numbers, and shipped as heavy freight. On top of that, demand has grown with the popularity of blacksmithing and knifemaking, while the supply of good antique anvils is limited and shrinking.
Anvils are also often priced roughly by weight. Since a useful forging anvil typically weighs somewhere around 75 pounds or more, the total adds up quickly. Here’s each factor in more detail.
Reason 1: lots of good steel
A working anvil needs a hard, tough steel face that won’t dent or chip under thousands of hammer blows. Good anvils are made from forged or cast steel of suitable alloys, not from cheap cast iron. You’re buying a lot of it: a general-purpose anvil weighs far more than most tools in a workshop. More steel means more raw material cost, and quality steel costs more than the cheapest iron.
Reason 2: heat treatment is hard to get right
Steel only becomes a good anvil face once it’s been properly hardened and tempered. Doing that on a single mass of steel weighing dozens or hundreds of pounds is much harder than hardening a chisel. The anvil has to be heated evenly, quenched in a controlled way and tempered, all without cracking or leaving soft spots. That takes equipment, energy and skilled labour, and a failed heat treatment can mean scrapping a whole anvil.
Reason 3: small production runs
Anvils are specialty tools. Compared with mass-produced hardware, relatively few are made, and some are made by small companies or individual makers. Small runs mean the costs of patterns, dies, machinery and skilled workers are spread over fewer units, so each anvil carries a larger share.
Finishing also takes time. Faces are ground flat, edges dressed, and hardy and pritchel holes formed or machined.
Reason 4: shipping something that heavy
Moving heavy, dense items is expensive. An anvil often has to travel from a foundry or forge, sometimes in another country, then to a distributor, then to you. Each leg adds freight cost. When you buy online, delivery can be a noticeable part of the total price.
Reason 5: demand, and a finite supply of old anvils
Interest in traditional crafts has grown, and television shows about blade forging have been widely credited with bringing in new hobbyists. More people now want anvils than a few decades ago.
At the same time, the supply of antique anvils is effectively fixed. The great 19th and early 20th century makers stopped production long ago, and the anvils they made are slowly being absorbed into hobbyists’ and collectors’ shops. With more buyers chasing a limited pool, prices for good used anvils have risen. Antiques in good condition now often hold their value well.
Reason 6: anvils last for generations
A good anvil, looked after, can outlast its owner. Many working anvils today are over a century old. Buyers know an anvil keeps its usefulness and resale value, so sellers have little reason to discount. You’re buying a tool that can be resold later, often for close to what you paid.
Why cheap anvils usually aren’t a bargain
Very cheap “anvils” sold through hardware stores and online marketplaces are often made from soft cast iron. Smiths call these “anvil-shaped objects”. They:
- Dent and chip under forging blows
- Absorb much of the hammer’s energy, so the work moves slowly
- Can crack, especially at the horn or heel
Many beginners who buy one end up replacing it, so it costs more overall. Our anvil review explains how to tell the difference.
How to pay less
- Start with a stopgap. A heavy block of solid steel stood on end costs far less than an anvil and works well for many projects. See our guide to poorboy blacksmith tools.
- Join a local blacksmithing group. Anvils often change hands within groups, sometimes at fair prices, and members can help you check one before you buy.
- Look for sound antiques. A used anvil with some honest wear but a good face and rebound can be great value. Learn how to inspect a used anvil first, so you don’t pay for hidden damage or bad repairs.
- Don’t over-buy weight. A good anvil in roughly the 75 to 150 pound range covers most hobby work. See how heavy a blacksmith anvil should be.
- Collect it yourself if you can, to avoid freight costs. Bring lifting help.
- Be patient. Good deals do turn up at farm sales, estate sales and auctions, but rarely on the day you start looking.
For how the anvil fits into overall hobby costs, see is blacksmithing a cheap hobby? and our essential blacksmithing kit guide.