What to bring
A few simple items make an anvil inspection much more reliable:
- A steel ball bearing, around 1 inch (25 mm) is a common size, for the rebound test
- A small hammer, around 1 to 2 pounds, for rebound and ring tests
- A straight edge or steel rule, to check the face for sway
- A tape measure, to check size and hardy hole dimensions
- A torch (flashlight), to look for cracks and repairs
- A wire brush, to clean a small area, with the seller’s permission
- Your phone, for photos of markings to research later
- Lifting help or a trolley, if you might take it home
Ask before brushing, testing or moving anything. It’s someone else’s anvil until you’ve paid for it.
First look: shape, type and markings
Before testing, look the anvil over:
- What type is it? London pattern, double-horn, farrier or block. See our anvil review for the differences.
- Markings. A maker’s name, logo, serial number or weight stamp can tell you a lot. Many older English anvils show weight in three numbers in the hundredweight system. Our article on how heavy an anvil should be explains how to read them.
- Overall proportion. Does the body look solid under the face, or thin at the waist?
- Rust. Surface rust is cosmetic and cleans up. Deep pitting on the face matters more.
The rebound test
The rebound test is the most useful single check of a face’s hardness and condition.
With a ball bearing:
- Hold the ball at a fixed height above the face. Ten inches (25 cm) is a convenient reference.
- Drop it straight down (don’t throw it) and watch how high it bounces.
- Repeat across the face: near the horn, the middle, near the hardy hole and toward the edges.
A hard, sound steel face bounces the ball back a large proportion of the drop height. Many smiths are happy with something in the region of 70 percent or more, and good anvils often do better. A soft or damaged face, or soft cast iron, bounces it noticeably less.
With a hammer: tap the face lightly with a relaxed grip and feel how readily the hammer springs back. A lively face throws the hammer up. A dead face lets it sit.
What to look for: consistency. Rebound should be broadly similar across the working area. A patch where the ball or hammer suddenly goes dead can point to a crack, a separated face plate or a soft repair in that area.
The ring test (and its limits)
Tap the face, horn and heel with a small hammer and listen.
- A clear ring is typical of a steel or steel-faced anvil in sound condition.
- A dull thud across the whole anvil can suggest cast iron. But some good anvils are naturally quiet, such as Fisher anvils, which have a cast body and steel face, and anvils sitting on soft surfaces sound duller.
- A change in tone in one area, such as a dull, buzzy or “dead” patch on an otherwise ringing face, can indicate a crack or a face plate that’s partly separated from the body.
Treat ring as a clue, not a verdict. Rebound and visual inspection tell you more.
Checking the face
The face is the main thing you’re paying for.
- Sway. Lay a straight edge along the face. A gentle dip in the middle is common on old anvils, and often still very usable. A deep sway limits flat work.
- Dents and chips. Small marks are normal. Deep dents or large chips in the main working area reduce usability.
- Cracks. Look closely with a torch, especially near the hardy and pritchel holes and at the edges.
- Delamination. On older anvils with a steel plate welded to a wrought iron body, look along the sides for a seam between plate and body that has opened. Combine that with rebound and tone checks over the area.
- Hardness. If the seller is happy for you to try, a file should skate across a hardened face rather than biting easily. Test only in an unobtrusive spot at the edge.
Edges, horn and heel
- Edges. Chipped edges are very common and often workable. Many smiths deliberately keep one edge section sharp and radius the rest. Be cautious about large missing chunks, or edges that have been heavily welded up.
- Horn. Check the horn for cracks, a broken tip or signs of repair. A shortened horn is less versatile, but it isn’t always a deal-breaker.
- Heel. The heel (behind the hardy hole) is relatively thin on many London-pattern anvils and can be damaged or broken off. A missing heel reduces value significantly.
- Feet and base. Look for cracked or broken feet, which can affect how securely the anvil mounts.
Hardy and pritchel holes
- Measure the hardy hole. Size determines which hardy tools fit. Common sizes include 3/4 inch and 1 inch.
- Check for damage: cracks around the holes, deformed edges, or tools jammed inside.
- Check the pritchel hole is clear and round.
Repairs and resurfacing
Repairs aren’t automatically bad, but poor repairs are common:
- Welded-up faces or edges. Look for weld beads, colour changes and different textures. A repair done with soft filler rod can leave the face soft in that area. Rebound over the repair will often show it.
- Milled or ground faces. A perfectly flat, freshly machined face on an old anvil may mean someone has ground it flat. On a steel-faced anvil, heavy grinding removes some of the limited hard layer. The anvil may look great while having less useful life left.
- Fresh paint. Paint can hide cracks and repairs. Look closely and ask what’s underneath.
Ask the seller directly whether the anvil has been welded or resurfaced. An honest seller will tell you what they know.
Spotting cast iron
Signs the anvil may be soft cast iron rather than steel:
- Poor rebound everywhere
- A dull thud everywhere (bearing in mind some good anvils are naturally quiet)
- Rough, grainy surfaces and visible casting seams
- Cast-in rather than stamped lettering, on some cheap modern examples
- A very low asking price for the size
A modern cast iron “anvil-shaped object” isn’t worth paying anvil prices for. See our anvil review.
Weighing it up
| Check | Good sign | Caution sign |
|---|---|---|
| Rebound | High and consistent across the face | Low overall, or dead patches |
| Ring | Clear and even | Dull or buzzy patches on a ringing face |
| Face | Mostly flat, light marks | Deep sway, deep dents, cracks |
| Face plate | No visible seam | Open seam along the side |
| Edges | Some chips, solid otherwise | Large missing chunks, heavy welding |
| Horn and heel | Intact | Cracked, broken or repaired |
| Hardy hole | Standard size, undamaged | Cracked, distorted, non-standard |
| Repairs | None, or skilled and hard | Soft welds, heavy milling, fresh paint |
Using what you find
Few used anvils are perfect. Honest wear, like chipped edges and a slight sway, is normal and often reflected in the price already. More serious problems, like a separated face, soft repairs, a broken heel or poor rebound, are reasons to negotiate firmly or walk away.
Used anvil prices can be high. Our article on why anvils are so expensive explains why. If you buy, mount it properly before you start. See how to make an anvil stand. For the rest of a beginner’s setup, read our essential blacksmithing kit guide.