What an anvil is
An anvil is a heavy block of hard metal that you shape hot metal on. When a hammer drives hot steel against it, the anvil’s mass and hardness stop the steel from moving away, so the blow’s energy goes into reshaping the workpiece instead. The flat top is the face. The cone-shaped projection is the horn. The square hole near the tail end is the hardy hole, and the smaller round hole is the pritchel hole.
A note on how this review works: we haven’t run a lab test of named products. Instead, this is a review of anvil categories. It covers what each type does well, where it falls short and what to check before you hand over money. That’s usually more useful for a first purchase, because what’s available second-hand varies so much from place to place.
How to judge any anvil
Whatever the brand or age, these are the qualities that matter:
- A hard face. A hardened steel face resists denting and returns the hammer’s energy. A soft face dents under missed blows and feels “dead”.
- Good rebound. Drop a hammer or steel ball on the face. A hard, well-supported face bounces it back a long way. A soft or cracked one doesn’t. Our guide to inspecting a used anvil explains the test.
- Mass under the hammer. What counts most is how much metal sits directly beneath where you strike. A compact, chunky anvil can outperform a longer one of similar weight that has a thin waist and long horn.
- A reasonably flat face. A slight sway (dip) is common on old anvils and often still workable. Deep dents, chips and cracks are not.
- Usable edges. Some edges with a gentle radius are useful for bending and drawing out. Sharp edges tend to chip and leave cold shuts in the work.
- A hardy hole that fits standard tools. Check the size, because it decides which hardy tools you can buy off the shelf.
Anvil types compared
| Type | Typical face | Strengths | Weaknesses | Beginner verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Forged steel (new) | Hardened throughout the top | Durable, consistent, good rebound | Highest price | Excellent if budget allows |
| Cast steel (new) | Hardened, quality depends on maker | Good value from reputable makers | Quality varies by maker and heat treatment | Very good from a known maker |
| Antique wrought iron with steel face | Forge-welded steel plate | Often affordable per pound, characterful | Wear, repairs, possible face delamination | Good if it passes inspection |
| Cast iron | Unhardened iron | Cheap and widely sold | Soft, dents easily, poor rebound, can chip or crack | Not recommended for forging |
| Improvised steel block | Usually unhardened mild steel | Cheap or free | No horn or hardy hole, softer face | A fine stopgap |
Forged steel
Forged anvils are made by shaping hot steel under heavy presses or hammers, then hardening the working surface. German makers such as Peddinghaus and Refflinghaus are long-established names in this category. Forged anvils are usually the most expensive new option. Most buyers pay for them because they want an anvil they’ll never need to replace.
Cast steel
Cast steel anvils are poured into moulds and then heat treated. Done well, they make excellent working anvils, and many working smiths use them. The key words are “done well”. Quality depends heavily on the alloy and heat treatment, so stick with makers that have a solid reputation in blacksmithing groups and published hardness information. Cheap cast steel anvils from unfamiliar sellers vary more. Some are decent, and some have soft faces or rough casting. It’s worth checking recent user reports before buying.
Antique wrought iron with a steel face
Many 19th and early 20th century anvils, including well-known English makes like Peter Wright and Mousehole, have a wrought iron body with a hardened steel face plate forge-welded on top. A sound example can be a lovely tool and often costs less per pound than a new forged anvil. The risks are wear, chipped edges, old welding repairs and, occasionally, a face plate that has started to separate from the body. Inspect carefully. A few antique types, such as Fisher anvils, were made with a cast iron body and a steel face, and they’re known for being unusually quiet.
Cast iron
Plain cast iron anvils are sold widely through hardware stores and online marketplaces because they’re cheap to make. Cast iron is not hardened like a steel face, so it dents and chips under forging blows and absorbs much of the hammer’s energy. Smiths often call these “anvil-shaped objects” (ASOs). They can be fine as a paperweight, for light cold work or for jewellery-scale tapping. As a forging anvil they’re usually a false economy.
Improvised steel blocks
A chunk of solid steel stood on end, such as a large round bar drop or a forklift tine section, can work surprisingly well, because all its mass is right under the hammer. It won’t have a horn or hardy hole, and the face is usually softer than a proper anvil. Still, it’s a perfectly respectable way to start. Our guide to poorboy blacksmith tools covers the options.
Anvil patterns: London, double-horn, farrier, block
- London pattern. The classic English-speaking shape, with a horn, a step (or table) and a flat face with hardy and pritchel holes in the heel. It’s versatile and familiar.
- Double-horn (continental or European). It has a round horn on one end and a flat or square horn on the other. Many smiths like the extra shapes for bending and drawing.
- Farrier anvils. These are designed for shaping horseshoes, often with clip horns and turning cams. Many work fine for general smithing, though some are lighter in the waist than a general-purpose anvil.
- Block or post anvils. These are simple, compact shapes that put lots of mass under a small face. They’re popular with bladesmiths.
For a first anvil, any of these will do general work. A London or double-horn pattern gives you the most features.
Spotting an anvil-shaped object
Signs that an anvil may be soft cast iron:
- A very low price for its size
- A rough, grainy surface with visible casting seams
- A dull thud rather than any ring or bounce when struck
- A hammer that barely bounces off the face
- Listings that mention “cast iron” in small print, or that are vague about material
When in doubt, ask the seller what the face is made of and whether it’s hardened. A reputable maker will tell you.
New or used?
New gives you a known quality, no hidden damage and, from good makers, a published face hardness. Used can be cheaper per pound, but you take on the risk of wear or bad repairs, and good second-hand anvils often sell quickly. Antiques in good condition have kept their value well. If you go used, take a small hammer and a steel ball bearing, and read our used anvil inspection guide first.
Either way, prices can be a shock. Our article on why anvils are so expensive explains what you’re paying for.
What weight should you look for?
For general beginner forging, many smiths suggest something in the region of 75 to 150 pounds (roughly 35 to 70 kg) as a practical range, and heavier is fine if you can move and afford it. Mass under the hammer and good mounting matter as much as the number on the side. We go into detail in how heavy should a blacksmith anvil be?
Whatever you buy, mount it firmly at the right height. Our guide to making an anvil stand covers that.
So what is the best anvil you can buy?
There isn’t one answer. The best anvil for a beginner is usually the best-quality steel anvil you can afford in a sensible weight range: one with a hard face, good rebound and a standard hardy hole. A well-made forged or cast steel anvil from a reputable maker is the safe choice. A sound antique is often the best value. A solid steel block is a good stopgap. A cheap cast iron ASO is the one to skip.
For how the anvil fits with the rest of your setup, see our beginner’s essential blacksmithing kit.